Why Should States Abandon Lottery Revenues?

In the last century, states have increasingly turned to lotteries to raise money. They argue that the proceeds of these games benefit a specific public good, such as education. But research suggests that this argument is misleading and ignores the reality that lottery revenues are a form of taxation that disproportionately impacts lower-income people. Despite these concerns, lottery proponents continue to promote the idea that lotteries are the answer to all state budget problems. This article discusses how these arguments mislead and why lotteries should be abolished.

The practice of making decisions and determining fates by drawing lots has a long history, dating at least to the Bible. The casting of lots to distribute land among the Israelites is described in the book of Numbers. Similarly, Roman emperors used lotteries to give away slaves and other property during Saturnalian feasts. Private individuals also began to hold lotteries to sell goods, services, and even properties for more than could be feasibly obtained through a public sale.

Although it is difficult to establish the first public lotteries, historians can trace the roots of modern lotteries back to the Low Countries in the 15th century, where records of public lotteries selling tickets to raise funds for town walls and other construction projects have been found. In the early 18th century, Benjamin Franklin ran a lottery to help fund the Continental Congress, and John Hancock and George Washington both conducted lotteries to raise money for their colleges (Boston Mercantile Journal, 1748).

These public lotteries typically offer either a lump sum or an annuity payment. A lump sum grants immediate cash, while an annuity consists of payments over time, which can be beneficial for those seeking retirement income. The choice of a lump sum or an annuity is based on individual financial goals and the applicable rules surrounding the particular lottery.

When choosing numbers for a lottery ticket, many players choose their birthdays or other personal identifiers (such as home addresses or social security numbers). These types of numbers have a higher frequency than random numbers and thus increase the chances of winning. However, this method is not foolproof. The probability of a number appearing on a lottery ticket is actually dependent on the total number of tickets sold and the distribution of those tickets between low and high rollers.

Another common mistake is selecting a lottery game with too few numbers. While the odds of winning are lower, so is the chance of winning a substantial prize. A smaller prize, however, is still better than none at all. Lastly, players should avoid numbers that are commonly used in other lotteries or for other purposes. This can reduce the overall likelihood of winning. To avoid these mistakes, study the odds of a particular lottery game and experiment with scratch-off tickets. Look for patterns in the “random” outside numbers and pay special attention to the singletons, which are those that appear only once. Usually, a high proportion of singletons indicates a winner.